{
  "target": "E08",
  "section": 4,
  "version": 1,
  "status": "authored design; implementation not authorized",
  "checklist-obligation": "- [ ] **E08 \u2014 Wider purpose, including humans and goal formation.** **OPEN:** evidence for all four apex requirements, including participant feedback and accountable formation of goals. The choice of an already supplied task is insufficient for goal formation.",
  "nodes": [
    {
      "id": "E08-1",
      "pattern": "wm-purpose-and-account/recipient-benefit-shapes-the-model",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/wm-walkthroughs/collections/purpose-and-account/recipient-benefit-shapes-the-model.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "58d076853e980a106d2dffa8a3dfa580bd9fad5352df24f3536d5199003a7022",
      "reading-url": "/2026-09-15-wm-patterns-purpose-and-account.html#recipient-benefit-shapes-the-model",
      "title": "Bind the four ruled requirements",
      "application": "Use September 9 Item 26 and apex-thesis-v1: A records carry warrant; B one queryable self-account; C feedback reaches every participant; D accountable next-action choice including goal formation. Produce four separate requirement/evidence subjects. Joe rejected reducing these institutional requirements to unexplained weights.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    },
    {
      "id": "E08-2",
      "pattern": "wm-qualifying-run/certificate-and-world-must-meet",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/wm-walkthroughs/collections/qualifying-run/certificate-and-world-must-meet.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "9da525759d36ead829b7c7564bc6d7668bf329fa00466cddf7fd6db08f7e2bd5",
      "reading-url": "/2026-09-15-wm-patterns-qualifying-run.html#certificate-and-world-must-meet",
      "title": "A: preserve warrant with the record",
      "application": "Retain each assertion with derivation, original evidence, authority and limits through storage and retrieval. Demonstrate that a recipient can inspect the warrant, not only a trimmed conclusion. Bind to E02 rather than commission a parallel evidence store.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    },
    {
      "id": "E08-3",
      "pattern": "wm-qualifying-run/complete-acquisition-universe",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/wm-walkthroughs/collections/qualifying-run/complete-acquisition-universe.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "b04d534795d2bc0956622b289b172f02e768fcf93098efbdb559974a90fa3289",
      "reading-url": "/2026-09-15-wm-patterns-qualifying-run.html#complete-acquisition-universe",
      "title": "B: make one queryable self-account",
      "application": "Declare the stack-state/provenance query and its required universe. Join the existing evidence vocabularies without hiding incompatible meanings or missing records. Show reconstitution and honest holes in the answer; an empty projection is not proof that nothing is missing.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    },
    {
      "id": "E08-4",
      "pattern": "wm-purpose-and-account/recipient-benefit-shapes-the-model",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/wm-walkthroughs/collections/purpose-and-account/recipient-benefit-shapes-the-model.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "58d076853e980a106d2dffa8a3dfa580bd9fad5352df24f3536d5199003a7022",
      "reading-url": "/2026-09-15-wm-patterns-purpose-and-account.html#recipient-benefit-shapes-the-model",
      "title": "C: deliver feedback to every participant",
      "application": "Name the actual human, agent and stakeholder recipients for the work, their delivery paths and evidence of receipt/use. Retain disagreements and inaccessible participants. A message emitted into a log does not show that the participant received or could act on it.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    },
    {
      "id": "E08-5",
      "pattern": "workshop/accountable-next-action-choice",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/futon3/library/workshop/accountable-next-action-choice.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "b66d0944e798356cfe3052fe4dd3863a904ae02d076c1b52d2fe48c981d91b3c",
      "reading-url": "#source-workshop--accountable-next-action-choice",
      "title": "D: form and choose goals accountably",
      "application": "Separate problem discovery, goal proposal, authorized adoption and action choice. Retain concerns, alternatives, uncertainty and who may revise priorities. Selecting a supplied ticket is not goal formation; simulated demand cannot become participant preference by relabeling.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    },
    {
      "id": "E08-6",
      "pattern": "wm-purpose-and-account/recipient-benefit-shapes-the-model",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/wm-walkthroughs/collections/purpose-and-account/recipient-benefit-shapes-the-model.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "58d076853e980a106d2dffa8a3dfa580bd9fad5352df24f3536d5199003a7022",
      "reading-url": "/2026-09-15-wm-patterns-purpose-and-account.html#recipient-benefit-shapes-the-model",
      "title": "Check the composed institutional arrangement",
      "application": "Test all four claims together on actual work: can participants retrieve the warranted account, receive feedback and question or revise the proposed goal through their authority? Retain independent findings and the consequences. No one successful query or accepted goal proposal proves all four.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    }
  ],
  "relations": [
    {
      "from": "E08-1",
      "to": "E08-2",
      "kind": "requires-result",
      "because": "The ruled subjects fix what counts as warrant."
    },
    {
      "from": "E08-2",
      "to": "E08-3",
      "kind": "requires-result",
      "because": "Queryable answers must preserve the warranted records rather than summaries without derivations."
    },
    {
      "from": "E08-3",
      "to": "E08-4",
      "kind": "requires-result",
      "because": "The shared account supplies meaningful feedback rather than disconnected notifications."
    },
    {
      "from": "E08-4",
      "to": "E08-5",
      "kind": "requires-result",
      "because": "Received concerns and disagreements inform accountable goal proposals."
    },
    {
      "from": "E08-5",
      "to": "E08-6",
      "kind": "requires-result",
      "because": "Goal adoption and the other three requirements must be tested together."
    },
    {
      "from": "E08-6",
      "to": "E08-1",
      "kind": "revision-feedback",
      "because": "A failed distinguishing control or consumer mismatch reopens the original scope/meaning; retain the failed claim rather than weakening it. Relevant controls: Reject invented apex criteria, simulated demand called preference, supplied-task selection called goal formation, unsupported human-benefit claims and feedback logged without consequence."
    }
  ],
  "dependencies": [
    "E01",
    "WM-13",
    "R19",
    "E10"
  ],
  "worked-situation": "The system chooses an existing ticket efficiently, while a participant needs a different unresolved problem addressed. That proves a choice among inputs, not accountable goal formation or benefit. The participant\u2019s concern must have a traceable route to a proposed, authorized goal.",
  "distinguishing-controls": "Reject invented apex criteria, simulated demand called preference, supplied-task selection called goal formation, unsupported human-benefit claims and feedback logged without consequence.",
  "open-decisions-and-limits": "The four requirement names and their status are ruled, not open. Their computational/institutional realization and task-specific evidence criteria still require design review; no weights or autonomous goal-setting authority are invented.",
  "sources": [
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/CHECKLIST-fundamentals.md",
      "sha256": "751ccfb00e4865c63734ac5147b9e6df66b48ee9697a7e20869d97a11467b81b",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/DESIGN-REQUIREMENTS-apex-2026-09-09.md",
      "sha256": "79228ad2299e639b427592f2eb24d4a80fadb9891271ca4bfe1211bf0a27f21c",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/RULINGS-walkthrough-2026-09-07.md",
      "sha256": "e8034618d4677ccb3a2d14f4bae8f470d5499968fabebe2ee6446c516f4ea6b3",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/RULINGS-walkthrough-2026-09-09.md",
      "sha256": "94222af425799985990929fd71e8dccf988ef4ced29958a96a188198964059c7",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/RULINGS-walkthrough-2026-09-12.md",
      "sha256": "9a20cbb57e57c9c9f5c3c19e67be663de1b7f779d45b92734b01f48c53a575e0",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/SPEC-cascade-policy-semantics-2026-09-15.md",
      "sha256": "2744a5c013a787b521b01849326a2216c477f839bf364c4920ac348391003334",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/COMPLETION-LIST-plop2026-2026-09-12.md",
      "sha256": "cdb06820677265ee4649a6324824fffd570c4a9710cce97717b028124fdf0d20",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/TN-row20-census-2026-09-12.md",
      "sha256": "dc7cec13147578130a875c0541c80dba65d3ffc1c21f4abf149b641d92b1a22c",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon3c/holes/excursions/apex-thesis.json",
      "sha256": "4288034fd4bb9ab69c13a3744130446f90da9520806f2835940691726fc3c87d",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    }
  ],
  "authored-content-sha256": "6ad6935c9196b751960a66e891a5ec562bbc77543e68999722b11b16e31e6b6f"
}