{
  "target": "R17-variants",
  "section": 3,
  "version": 1,
  "status": "authored design; implementation not authorized",
  "checklist-obligation": "- [ ] **R17-variants \u2014 R17', R17'', R17''', R16\u2192R6.** **UNRESOLVED:** separately establish exploration-bonus/core separation controls (P095), exact embedding-proposal\u2192BMR verdict (P096), genesis/admission/repeated review (P097\u2013P099, WM-14), and live outcome\u2192proposal\u2192later selection (P100\u2013P105); generation alone is not validated structure learning. Built evidence: P095\u2013P105 separately inventory these claims: exploration bonus source, proposal/reduction machinery, missing connected genesis and outcome-to-proposal learning, and historical comparison claims",
  "nodes": [
    {
      "id": "R17-variants-1",
      "pattern": "wm-connected-learning/proposal-earns-later-use",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/wm-walkthroughs/collections/connected-learning/proposal-earns-later-use.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "9360fd57ba6b4568ecbef37fa867e5c8d94b9c9272a5081aa22863a29a97ccbd",
      "reading-url": "/2026-09-15-wm-patterns-connected-learning.html#proposal-earns-later-use",
      "title": "Separate the claim families",
      "application": "Create distinct subjects for P095 exploration/core separation, P096 embedding proposal/BMR, P097\u2013P099 genesis/admission/repeated review, and P100\u2013P105 outcome-to-proposal-to-choice. Preserve different evidence requirements; do not collapse them into one learning flag.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    },
    {
      "id": "R17-variants-2",
      "pattern": "wm-connected-learning/proposal-earns-later-use",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/wm-walkthroughs/collections/connected-learning/proposal-earns-later-use.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "9360fd57ba6b4568ecbef37fa867e5c8d94b9c9272a5081aa22863a29a97ccbd",
      "reading-url": "/2026-09-15-wm-patterns-connected-learning.html#proposal-earns-later-use",
      "title": "Test exploration and embedding alternatives",
      "application": "For P095 retain the unchanged core objective alongside the separately governed bonus. For P096 bind the exact embedding proposal to its BMR verdict. These are separate branches with separate control populations, not serial proof of one another.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    },
    {
      "id": "R17-variants-3",
      "pattern": "cascades/edges-earn-permanence",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/futon3/library/cascades/edges-earn-permanence.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "3226ac2100b997247e1d40fb2df071907ed78a6a28ddeb150ac59613df13d37b",
      "reading-url": "#source-cascades--edges-earn-permanence",
      "title": "Review genesis and repeated relations",
      "application": "Bind generated sources to admission and later independent reviews. For relation promotion retain distinct contexts and reviewer reasons; repeated use is evidence for review, not automatic permanence.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    },
    {
      "id": "R17-variants-4",
      "pattern": "wm-connected-learning/proposal-earns-later-use",
      "source": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/wm-walkthroughs/collections/connected-learning/proposal-earns-later-use.flexiarg",
      "source-sha256": "9360fd57ba6b4568ecbef37fa867e5c8d94b9c9272a5081aa22863a29a97ccbd",
      "reading-url": "/2026-09-15-wm-patterns-connected-learning.html#proposal-earns-later-use",
      "title": "Join live outcomes to later proposals",
      "application": "Retain the actual R16 outcome, resulting proposal, independent verdict and later R6 selection for P100\u2013P105. Preserve rejected proposals and later failures. Report each claim\u2019s status independently.",
      "status": "authored application, not executed or independently accepted"
    }
  ],
  "relations": [
    {
      "from": "R17-variants-1",
      "to": "R17-variants-2",
      "kind": "requires-scope",
      "because": "Separate P095\u2013P105 claim identities govern this independently evidenced branch."
    },
    {
      "from": "R17-variants-1",
      "to": "R17-variants-3",
      "kind": "requires-scope",
      "because": "Separate P095\u2013P105 claim identities govern this independently evidenced branch."
    },
    {
      "from": "R17-variants-1",
      "to": "R17-variants-4",
      "kind": "requires-scope",
      "because": "Separate P095\u2013P105 claim identities govern this independently evidenced branch."
    },
    {
      "from": "R17-variants-3",
      "to": "R17-variants-4",
      "kind": "requires-result",
      "because": "Later consumption of a generated pattern requires its actual admission; P095/P096 controls remain separate claims."
    },
    {
      "from": "R17-variants-4",
      "to": "R17-variants-1",
      "kind": "revision-feedback",
      "because": "A failed distinguishing control or consumer mismatch reopens the original scope/meaning; retain the failed claim rather than weakening it. Relevant controls: Use bonus-off/core-invariant controls, wrong embedding hashes, absent independent review, repeated-context inflation and later-choice mismatch. Retain separate results for all four claim groups."
    }
  ],
  "dependencies": [
    "R17",
    "R16",
    "R6",
    "WM-14",
    "E06"
  ],
  "worked-situation": "An embedding proposal is accepted, but no later selection reads it. P096 may have a bounded verdict while P100\u2013P105 remain missing. A promoted edge used repeatedly in one copied context does not establish cross-context usefulness.",
  "distinguishing-controls": "Use bonus-off/core-invariant controls, wrong embedding hashes, absent independent review, repeated-context inflation and later-choice mismatch. Retain separate results for all four claim groups.",
  "open-decisions-and-limits": "Exact P095\u2013P105 source scope comes from the pinned completion inventory. No generation, promotion or new bonus law is authorized here.",
  "sources": [
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/p4ng/CHECKLIST-fundamentals.md",
      "sha256": "751ccfb00e4865c63734ac5147b9e6df66b48ee9697a7e20869d97a11467b81b",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/DESIGN-REQUIREMENTS-apex-2026-09-09.md",
      "sha256": "79228ad2299e639b427592f2eb24d4a80fadb9891271ca4bfe1211bf0a27f21c",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/RULINGS-walkthrough-2026-09-07.md",
      "sha256": "e8034618d4677ccb3a2d14f4bae8f470d5499968fabebe2ee6446c516f4ea6b3",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/RULINGS-walkthrough-2026-09-09.md",
      "sha256": "94222af425799985990929fd71e8dccf988ef4ced29958a96a188198964059c7",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/RULINGS-walkthrough-2026-09-12.md",
      "sha256": "9a20cbb57e57c9c9f5c3c19e67be663de1b7f779d45b92734b01f48c53a575e0",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/SPEC-cascade-policy-semantics-2026-09-15.md",
      "sha256": "2744a5c013a787b521b01849326a2216c477f839bf364c4920ac348391003334",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/COMPLETION-LIST-plop2026-2026-09-12.md",
      "sha256": "cdb06820677265ee4649a6324824fffd570c4a9710cce97717b028124fdf0d20",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon2/holes/labs/wm-contract/TN-row20-census-2026-09-12.md",
      "sha256": "dc7cec13147578130a875c0541c80dba65d3ffc1c21f4abf149b641d92b1a22c",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    },
    {
      "file": "/home/joe/code/futon3c/holes/excursions/apex-thesis.json",
      "sha256": "4288034fd4bb9ab69c13a3744130446f90da9520806f2835940691726fc3c87d",
      "scope": "dated source; statements retain their own authority and limits"
    }
  ],
  "authored-content-sha256": "6ad6935c9196b751960a66e891a5ec562bbc77543e68999722b11b16e31e6b6f"
}